Skip to content
Español

Leave Us a Review

Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.


Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.

What our customers say about us...

Profile photo of Ruth Defries

Ruth Defries

June 16, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Ruth Defries
"Andy and Matt have been very helpful keeping us up to date on our insurance. Whenever we need proof of insurance,etc, they are very prompt in their response."
We responded:
"Ruth, Thank you for your review and for trusting Andy Eyers State Farm with your insurance needs! We're glad to hear that you’ve found our pricing competitive and that Andy and Matt have been helpful in keeping your coverage up to date. Providing prompt service, whether it's proof of insurance, policy updates, or answering questions, is something we take pride in. We truly appreciate the opportunity to help protect your auto insurance, commercial insurance, and general liability insurance needs. Thank you for your support and for choosing our team. We look forward to being here whenever you need us! - Andy"
Profile photo of Michael Waldera

Michael Waldera

June 10, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Michael Waldera
"Alec is always helpful and appreciated."
We responded:
"Michael, Thank you for the 5-star review! We're glad to hear you found our rates reasonable and that Alec has been so helpful. Providing friendly, responsive service and helping our customers find the right auto, home, renters, and life insurance coverage at a great value is what our team strives for every day. We truly appreciate your trust in the Andy Eyers State Farm team. Alec will be thrilled to hear your kind words. Thank you for choosing us for your insurance needs, and we look forward to being here whenever you need us! -Andy"
Profile photo of Janis Lyskawa

Janis Lyskawa

June 5, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Janis Lyskawa
"Always have a great experience with anyone I talk to at Andy Eyers' office. Great team!!"
We responded:
"Janis- Thank you so much for your wonderful review! We're grateful to hear that you've had a great experience with everyone at Andy Eyers State Farm. Our team is committed to providing exceptional customer service and helping our customers find the right coverage for their auto insurance, home insurance, renters insurance, life insurance, and business insurance needs. We truly appreciate your trust in our Sun Prairie State Farm office. Reviews like yours mean a lot to our team and help others looking for a local insurance agency in Sun Prairie and the surrounding areas. Thank you for your support and for allowing us to help protect what matters most! -Andy"
Profile photo of Madison Graf

Madison Graf

June 1, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Madison Graf
"I met Andy at a networking event on Friday morning after a recent nightmare of a situation with Progressive. Was super friendly and listened to every issue I had with them and explained how State Farm might be a better fit and gave me his card. When I got back to the office I emailed him for a quote. Within 30 min of my email he had pulled together better policies than I was getting in the past. Obviously with my run in with my terrible broker, and her recommendation to Progressive, insurance has made me nervous and left me with 10 million questions. Andy spent the entire rest of the day reassuring my questions and followed up with me first thing Monday morning to confirm my needs, explain 10 million more questions at my level. After speaking with him I understand more about insurance in 2 hr then my last 10 years of searching for it. Not once did I feel like I was being sales pushed or talked down to or over my head. Obviously this is just the sign up- but if they handle claims even half as good as they handled this process with this level of kindness, understanding and efficiency I’m excited to be here!"
We responded:
"Madison- Thank you so much for taking the time to share your experience! It was a pleasure meeting you and learning about your situation. I'm glad we could help make the insurance process feel less overwhelming and provide clarity around your auto insurance and renters insurance coverage options. At Andy Eyers State Farm, we believe insurance should be about education, communication, and helping customers make informed decisions, not high-pressure sales tactics. I'm grateful for the opportunity to answer your questions and help you find coverage that better fits your needs. Our goal is to provide the same level of service throughout every stage of the customer journey, whether it's reviewing policies, updating coverage, or assisting with a claim. Thank you for trusting our Sun Prairie State Farm office with your insurance needs. We look forward to being here for you for many years to come! Welcome to the Andy Eyers State Farm family, and thank you again for your recommendation! -Andy"
Profile photo of Beach House Painting

Beach House Painting

May 15, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Beach House Painting
"My wife and I can’t say enough positive things about Andy Eyers. He takes the time to explain every detail of our policy, ensuring we had top-notch coverage. Andy and his staff in Sun Prairie are always quick to respond to our emails and calls, along with being friendly, knowledgeable and patient. We trust them completely and know they have our back. We’re so happy to hear that Andy Eyers will soon have another State Farm office in Fort Atkinson, what a great addition to the community!"
We responded:
"Thank you so much for the thoughtful review and for trusting State Farm with your insurance needs! We truly appreciate you taking the time to share your experience with our Sun Prairie team. Helping customers understand their coverage and making sure they feel confident in their protection is always our goal. We’re grateful for the opportunity to assist with your auto, life, homeowners, workers compensation, accident, and mortgage insurance needs. Your support means a lot to us, and we’re excited to continue serving both the Sun Prairie and Fort Atkinson communities. Thanks again for being part of the Andy Eyers State Farm family! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ -Andy"
Profile photo of Lena Ugren

Lena Ugren

May 6, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Lena Ugren
"Matt is super fast and great to work with! I highly recommend Andy Eyers State Farm office!"
We responded:
"Lena, Thank you for the awesome review and recommendation! We’re so glad Matt was able to provide fast, reliable service and make the process easy for you. At State Farm agent Andy Eyers State Farm, we’re proud to help customers with auto insurance, home insurance, and personalized coverage throughout Fort Atkinson, Sun Prairie, Madison, and surrounding Wisconsin communities. We truly appreciate your support! -Andy "
Profile photo of Dan Capadona

Dan Capadona

May 1, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Dan Capadona
"Matt was great to work with. We talked on several occasions about some hail damage on my roof. He was honest and we had very reasonable conversations. Insurance claims and home damage are stressful, but he made the process better for me."
We responded:
"Dan, Thank you so much for the thoughtful review! We’re glad Matt was able to help make a stressful situation a little easier. Navigating roof hail damage, home insurance claims, and coverage questions can feel overwhelming, so having honest conversations and clear guidance matters. We appreciate you trusting our team to help through the process, and we’re thankful for the opportunity to assist with your homeowners insurance needs. Thanks again for supporting our local State Farm office and for sharing your experience! -Andy"
Profile photo of bowhunt4life72

bowhunt4life72

May 1, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by bowhunt4life72
"Matt did a great job setting up my policies, and saved my a bunch by bundling my home and auto! Thanks!"
We responded:
"Thank you for the review of working with Matt! We work hard to have great customer service and take care of your needs! We appreciate you! -Andy "
Profile photo of Brad Fritter [C]

Brad Fritter [C]

April 23, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Brad Fritter [C]
"Andy is knowledgeable and does a great job taking care of his customers!"
We responded:
"Brad, Thank you for the kind words! We truly appreciate you recognizing the time and care we put into helping our customers. Providing knowledgeable guidance and making sure people feel confident in their coverage is what we’re all about. If you’re in Sun Prairie or the surrounding Wisconsin communities and need help with auto, home, or life insurance, we’re always here to help! -Andy "
Profile photo of Amy Draper

Amy Draper

April 18, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Amy Draper
"Alec at the Andy Ayer’s State Farm was very helpful and efficient in getting me a quote and the right coverage for my camper. I highly recommend him!"
We responded:
"Amy, Thanks so much, Amy! We really appreciate your feedback and your recommendation. I’m glad Alec made the process easy and helped you find the right camper coverage at a great price. It means a lot to serve customers in Sun Prairie and the surrounding communities. If you ever need help with auto, home, or camper insurance in Sun Prairie, WI, we’re always here to help. Don’t hesitate to reach out anytime! -Andy "
Profile photo of Mark Hennick

Mark Hennick

April 9, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Mark Hennick
"Andy cleaned up the mess caused by another agent."
We responded:
"Thanks so much for the great review Mark—we really appreciate you sharing your experience! I’m glad we were able to step in, fix the issues, and get everything back on track for you. At our State Farm office here in Sun Prairie, we take pride in helping people sort through insurance problems and making sure their auto insurance, home insurance, and overall coverage are set up correctly and easy to understand. If you ever need help reviewing your policies, comparing coverage, or just have questions about your insurance, we’re always here for you. Thanks again for trusting our team! -Andy"
Profile photo of Todd Narkis

Todd Narkis

April 8, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Todd Narkis
"Andy called me to introduce himself and within a matter of hours he had a new policy added to my portfolio that my prior agent was unable to secure. I appreciate his prompt service and ability to accomplish tasks."
We responded:
"Todd, I really appreciate you taking the time to share this. It was great connecting with you, and I’m glad we were able to quickly find a solution and get that policy added where others couldn’t. We take a lot of pride in being responsive and making things happen when our clients in the Fort Atkinson community need it most, so your feedback means a lot. Thanks again for trusting us with your property insurance—don’t hesitate to reach out anytime you need anything! -Andy"
Profile photo of Lisa Lietz-Ray

Lisa Lietz-Ray

March 16, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Lisa Lietz-Ray
"Although I am not an insurance client of this office, Andy Eyers is very timely in responses to business emails and correspondence as well as all of his other business dealings. He is very personable and a joy to work with."
We responded:
"Lisa, Thank you for the kind words! Even though you’re not currently an insurance client, it means a lot that you’ve noticed the level of communication and professionalism we strive for. At our office, we believe prompt responses, clear communication, and building strong relationships are just as important as providing great auto insurance, home insurance, and business insurance service. We appreciate the opportunity to work with great people in the community and are always here if you ever need help with insurance questions, coverage options, or a quote in the future. -Andy"
Profile photo of Aleah McGowan

Aleah McGowan

March 16, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Aleah McGowan
"Alec is extremely helpful! Not only from the fact that he was fast and clear, but also answering every single question I had (and I had lot of dumb ones). I cannot express the amazing experience I had working him"
We responded:
"Thanks so much for the kind words! Alec will be really glad to hear this. We’re happy he could take the time to walk through all your questions and make the process clear and easy. There’s no such thing as a dumb insurance question, and making sure you understand your auto and homeowners insurance coverage is exactly what we’re here for. We truly appreciate you trusting our team to help protect what matters most. If you ever need help with home or car insurance in Sun Prairie or the surrounding communities, Alec and the rest of our team are always here to help! -Andy"
Profile photo of Anne Finn

Anne Finn

March 11, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Anne Finn
"I switched to State Farm a few months back after hearing about their reasonable rates. Matt has been so helpful getting my new insurance set up and the transition was seamless. I highly recommend this team!"
We responded:
"Anne, Thank you for the great review and for choosing our State Farm agency! We're really glad to hear the switch went smoothly and that Matt was able to help make the transition easy. Taking the time to walk through options and make sure everything is set up correctly is something we take pride in. We appreciate the recommendation and look forward to continuing to help with your auto, home, and insurance needs here in Sun Prairie and the surrounding areas. If you ever have questions or need anything down the road, Matt and our team are always happy to help! -Andy"
Profile photo of Tammy

Tammy

March 11, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Tammy
"Absolutely positive experience with Matt My old home owner insurance policy was so expensive just to find out today they will not renew my policy in June because they are leaving the state. Thirty years with that company and never a claim. Looking forward to better coverage and great service."
We responded:
"Tammy, Thanks so much for sharing your experience and for trusting Matt to help with your coverage. After 30 years with the same company, getting a non-renewal notice can definitely be frustrating, especially with a claim-free history. We're really glad Matt could step in, review your options, and help you find homeowners insurance that offers strong protection and real value. Our goal is always to make insurance easier to understand and to be here when it matters most, especially when it comes to the claims process. If you ever have questions about your home, auto, or other coverage, our team is here to help. We appreciate you choosing our agency and look forward to taking great care of you! -Andy "
Profile photo of John Faludi

John Faludi

March 10, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by John Faludi
"Andy's staff responded right away when I had a request. Also, he recently explained a point to me about my insurance. Very helpful."
We responded:
"John, Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. We’re glad our team was able to respond quickly and help walk through your question. Insurance can sometimes feel complicated, so taking the time to explain the details and make sure everything makes sense is something we take seriously. We truly appreciate you trusting our office with your auto insurance and homeowners insurance needs. Our goal is always to provide helpful, responsive service to our customers in Sun Prairie, Madison, and the surrounding Wisconsin communities. If you ever have questions about your coverage, our State Farm team is always here to help. -Andy"
Profile photo of Brian Zblewski

Brian Zblewski

March 9, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Brian Zblewski
"Matt is very friendly, knowledgeable and convenient to work with!"
We responded:
"Brian, Thank you for the great feedback! We’re really glad to hear Matt made your experience friendly, knowledgeable, and easy to navigate. Taking the time to explain options and make sure everything is simple and convenient is exactly the level of service we strive to provide for everyone we work with. At our State Farm office, we believe insurance should feel straightforward and personal. Whether it’s auto insurance, home insurance, renters insurance, life insurance, or business coverage, our team is always here to answer questions and help you feel confident about your protection. Matt and the entire team work hard to make sure customers in Sun Prairie and the surrounding communities get clear advice, quick responses, and coverage that fits their needs. We truly appreciate you choosing our office and trusting us with your insurance. If you ever need anything or have questions down the road, we’re always here to help! -Andy"
Profile photo of Sam Garwo

Sam Garwo

March 6, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Sam Garwo
"Great experience...love the personal touch."
We responded:
"Sam, Thanks so much for the 5-star review! We really appreciate you taking the time to share your experience. Providing that personal touch is something our team truly cares about, and we’re glad it came through. Helping people in Sun Prairie and the surrounding communities understand their coverage and feel comfortable with their insurance is what we’re here for. Thanks again for the support! -Andy"
Profile photo of Ashley Leccesi

Ashley Leccesi

March 5, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Ashley Leccesi
"Helps in the community a ton and fast at replying."
We responded:
"Thank you for the kind review! Andy and our team is proud to support the Sun Prairie community and surrounding areas, and we always work hard to provide quick, helpful responses whenever someone needs assistance with their auto insurance, home insurance, or other coverage options. We truly appreciate your support and your trust in our State Farm team here in Sun Prairie, and we’re always here whenever you need us! -Andy"
Profile photo of Cindy Mickelson

Cindy Mickelson

February 26, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Cindy Mickelson
"When I reach out with a question or concern I get an immediate response. This is helpful for my piece of mind. Thank you"
We responded:
"Cindy, Thank you so much for the 5 stars and for sharing this. It really means a lot to all of us. We know that when you reach out with a question or concern, it’s usually important and sometimes even stressful. The last thing anyone wants is to wait around wondering what’s going on. That’s why staying responsive is such a big priority for our entire team. Whether you’re talking with Matt, Andy, Alec, or anyone here in the office, our goal is the same. Clear answers, quick follow up, and real conversations that give you confidence in your coverage. Insurance should never feel confusing or distant. It should feel accessible and personal. Knowing that our responsiveness gives you peace of mind tells us we’re doing what we set out to do. We truly appreciate you trusting us and we’re always here whenever you need us. -Andy"
Profile photo of Kevin Scheckel

Kevin Scheckel

February 21, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Kevin Scheckel
"Matt did a great job laying out my options. Appreciate the great customer service!"
We responded:
" Kevin, Thank you so much for the 5 stars and for sharing this! Matt takes a lot of pride in making sure options are clearly explained so you can make the best decision for your situation. Insurance shouldn’t feel confusing or rushed, and we’re glad you felt supported every step of the way. We truly appreciate your trust in our team. Whether it’s auto, home, life, or business insurance, we’re always here to provide the same level of service and attention whenever you need us. -Andy"
Profile photo of Margery Laube

Margery Laube

February 21, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Margery Laube
"Awesome service !"
We responded:
"Thank you so much for the 5 stars and the kind words! It truly means a lot to our team. We work hard to make insurance feel simple, straightforward, and actually helpful instead of confusing or overwhelming. Hearing that you had an awesome experience tells us we’re doing what we set out to do, and that’s to serve people the right way. Whether it’s auto insurance, home insurance, life insurance, or business coverage, our goal is always clear communication, quick follow up, and making sure everything is properly protected. We’re grateful you trusted us and we’re always here anytime you need us. -Andy"
Profile photo of Andrew Hotchkiss

Andrew Hotchkiss

February 20, 2026

1  out of  5
rating by Andrew Hotchkiss
"I had State Farm through an agent in McFarland who retired a few years ago. I was automatically sent to this agent as they were closest to me. They asked to discuss my plan with me in person, but basically spent the meeting trying to sell me life insurance and was, in my opinion, very pushy about it. Later I asked them to add someone to my renters insurance and they tried to get me to add the person to my auto insurance. Not the biggest deal, however I asked them not to try to get me to things like that or offer me things I don't ask about. They responded by explaining why they asked me to do that, and then asked if I wanted to save with drive and save. The exact thing I asked them not to do. My entire experience with this agent office has felt very impersonal, and I have expressed this to them over email with a similarly impersonal response. This is all just my opinion based on how I felt in talking with this office, which differed greatly from my previous experience with a different state farm office. I have recently switched to a different insurance company and will be saving money as well."
We responded:
"Thanks for sharing your experience. I genuinely appreciate you taking the time to explain what happened. I’m sorry to hear that your interactions with our office felt pushy and impersonal. That’s never the impression we want to leave. When we review coverage or suggest options like life insurance or additional auto coverage, the intent is to make sure there aren’t gaps and that clients are aware of ways they could be better protected, ensure coverage in the event of a claim, or potentially save money. That said, it should always feel helpful, not pressured. I also regret that our follow-up communication came across as impersonal. We strive to provide a personal, relationship-based experience, and it’s disappointing to hear we missed the mark for you. I truly wish you the best with your new insurance company and appreciate the time you trusted us with your auto and renters insurance. If you ever have questions in the future or would like to talk through anything, my door is always open. -Andy "
Profile photo of Shannon Urbina

Shannon Urbina

February 17, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Shannon Urbina
"Matt was nothing short of fantastic! He helped get a LOT of things properly protected for us! THANK YOU!"
We responded:
"Shannon- Thank you so much for the amazing review! We’re grateful you trusted Matt and our team to help you protect what matters most. Our goal is always to make sure your coverage is set up correctly and that you’re getting real value, not just a policy. We’re glad we could help with your auto insurance, motorcycle insurance, boat and watercraft insurance, flood insurance, renters insurance, property insurance, and general liability insurance. It’s also great to hear we were able to assist with workers’ compensation insurance, employee insurance, accident insurance, and life insurance so both your family and your business are fully protected. We’re proud to serve Sun Prairie and the Madison areas, helping families and business owners find the right coverage with clear guidance and personal service. If anyone in Sun Prairie or nearby communities is looking for a local insurance agency that takes the time to review everything in detail, we’re always happy to help. Thanks again for your trust and support! -Andy"